Decoding Reasons behind the Censorship fears of the Broadcasting Services Bill, 2024

In June 2024 , the government introduced a revised broadcasting bill where the government is drafting a bill to bring all news and news adjacent content on any online social media platform under its regulatory oversight. This regulation bill has triggered a lot of controversy and criticism over the fear that the government is trying greater control over online content. It has raised several questions on the freedom of speech and expression and government powers to regulate it. If the attempt sounds overreach, the modus operandi of drafting such a bill is even more. This article attempts to find out underlying issues within its drafting that are raising concerns over government overreach and constitutional values.
Last year, a broadcasting law was introduced that sought to replace the Cable Television Network Act of 1995 and revamp India’s regulatory framework for broadcasting services. Why has it made the rounds? A revised draft to the original bill was shared with key stakeholders in June 2024, in which it was revealed that it extended its regulatory ambit to encompass traditional broadcast media, OTT platforms, and introducing a new category for online content creators called digital news broadcasters. But the major concern lies in the way it has been introduced. The bill’s introduction was marred by a lack of transparency. Copies of the bill were distributed to selected stakeholders, excluding many key players and public interest groups. Such a secretive approach has excluded broader stakeholder participation, eroding trust in the legislative process. Transparency is crucial in democratic law-making, especially for legislation that impacts fundamental rights like freedom of expression. Also, restricting access to the bill prevented comprehensive review and critique from diverse perspectives. This can lead to an incomplete understanding of its potential impacts and the inclusion of valuable insights that could improve the bill. This restrictive approach needs to be removed to have a clear understanding regarding the objectives of the bill. There is a lot of vagueness and ambiguity in the bill, which rose more than a few eyebrows over the censorship of freedom of expression and speech. The bill states that any program transmitted as a broadcasting service must conform to the “program code." But no guidance has been provided on the formulation of the program code. The power to prescribe this code vests exclusively with the central government. Therefore, the code may vary with each broadcasting service; it has failed to provide guidelines with respect to the formulation of program code. This may lead to public scrutiny. Hence, the government needs to establish the guiding principles for the code to remove ambiguity. It would avoid granting unbridled powers to the executive and would safeguard constitutional values. It would help the government to not censor content critical of the government.
Another key issue is the setting up of the four-tier government mechanism to ensure compliance and to deal with content-related issues. It seems to be effective and exhaustive at the same time. The problem lying here is the presence of multiple bodies, which can lead to inefficient and inconsistent decision-making. Therefore, the removal of some of them whose works are overlapping can provide quick and efficient decision-making. Apart from it, there exists an advisory council entitled to make recommendations to the government regarding appeals made by self-regulatory bodies, but the bill fails to specify whether recommendations made by the council will be binding or not, and it seems to grant the final decision-making power within the hands of the central government with no means of appeal against any decision of the Centre. It would be better if some means were provided so that an appeal can be made against the decision of the Centre with which the public is not satisfied, along with the specification of the circumstances in which recommendations of the council will be binding or not. A broadcast advisory council is appointed by the government, which raises concerns over impartiality and potential influence of the government over regulations. Other modus operandi should be considered in the appointment of members to maintain impartiality, or otherwise it could undermine the objectivity needed while addressing issues related to freedom of speech and expression in regards to media. Satisfactory reasons should be provided by MIB on whether it is appropriate to have a differential framework for the same content based on the medium of dissemination.
The bill has expanded its scope from OTT and digital news to social media platforms and online video creators. It seeks to expand its definition of digital news broadcaster to include publishers of news and current affair content incorporating independent content creators on platforms such as YouTube, instagram and X, etc. These creators are required to intimate the government of their work, set up a content evaluation committee and only programmes certified by the committee would be allowed to run. Clearly, the bill seeks to regulate and control influencers’ works across various platforms. Such an attempt to control and regulate is a clear overreach that threatens the core principles of free speech and also hampers digital innovation. Influencers thrive to make content without the heavy-headed constraints typical of traditional media, and such stringent regulations can stifle creativity and restrict the diverse viewpoints that flourish online. Such constraints need to be reduced, which would enable the growth of an individual creator, digital entrepreneurship, and also doesn’t undermine the democratic nature of the internet, where diverse voices are celebrated, not censored. The ambiguous nature of the bill needs to be dealt with; otherwise, it could lead to arbitrary enforcement, disproportionately affecting small creators who lack resources to navigate through a complex regulatory framework.
Remember the Emergency in India, when freedom of expression was censored and opponents to the government were imprisoned? Surrounded by similar controversies, the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting is required to address the issues surrounding it, or otherwise it will create an emergency like situation. There is a need for transparency in the process involving the drafting of the bill. MIB should be accountable to take into consideration the reviews given by the public so that while making regulations, it should not violate the constitutional values and fundamental rights of the people.
Featured Images credits: Pinterest
Article by Sandhya
Edited by Yash Raj


Comments