Delhi's dilemma with air pollution
Updated: Jul 14, 2025

INTRODUCTION
The Supreme Court of India has acknowledged the right to clean air as a fundamental right. Nevertheless, in the national capital, the onset of winter, particularly following the festival of Diwali, reveals the impracticality of this vision as governmental authorities engage in a cycle of blame and the judiciary intervenes through Suo Motu cognizance. One of the most urgent and significant environmental problems that developing nations like India are dealing with is air pollution, a problem that cuts across time and space. According to a report by CNN Health, 3 of the 30 most polluted cities in the world are from India¹.
On 15th November 2024, Delhi surpassed Lahore in terms of being the most polluted city of the world with AQI over 1000, according to Swiss IQAir’s live rankings². The apprehensions regarding this grim situation was seriously first realized in 2016, when ‘The Great Smog’ hit the capital in a worst manner³. Afterwards, once again Delhi was put into the severe- plus category in 2018 and the trend continued. Despite the establishment of the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) and the implementation of various legislative measures and provisions, these initiatives have proven insufficient in mitigating the critical levels of hazardous air pollution.
This research aims to investigate the issue of poor air quality in Delhi and the underlying factors contributing to this problem. The study revealed that primary contributors to air pollution include stubble burning, vehicular emissions and industrial pollution. An evaluation of current governmental measures highlighted the gaps in the implementation as well as the contradictory behavior of the public, who, despite widespread dissatisfaction, refrain from taking any individual action. Furthermore, the impact of air pollution on the health of humans, flora, fauna and the broader environment has been given primary importance and discussed in detail. Additionally, a case study of Beijing has been included to draw parallels and extract lessons applicable to Delhi, given the similar challenges faced by urban centers globally. At last, a few policies have been recommended based on the entire study, hoping to achieve more promising outcomes.
METHODOLOGY
The methodology for the research report involves both qualitative and quantitative methods of analysis. This dual-faceted approach sought to engage with and analyze the diverse sub-themes associated with the issue of air pollution, integrating both primary and secondary data collection methods. The primary source included a comprehensive online survey which received a total of 154 responses. The survey was designed in a semi-structured manner, comprising both multiple choice and open ended questions, for getting a nuanced perspective. For further enrichment, secondary sources like online journals and websites have also been referred.
The Quantitative part of the analysis, illustrated in the forms of charts and diagrams, helps to understand the prevailing trends like the last 5 year trend of air pollution in Delhi and the other contributing sources. The survey part further reflects the awareness among people regarding government measures to curb air pollution, its overall evaluation, public perceptions etc. The Qualitative part of the analysis, focuses on deeper subthemes like- effectiveness and ambiguities in existing measures to control air pollution, adversarial impacts of air pollution on human and environmental health and the solutions other megacities are adopting, presented through the case of Beijing.
SURVEY OBSERVATION AND ANALYSIS
In order to proceed with the survey, an online questionnaire was circulated, which has received a total of 154 responses. It comprised a diverse set of questions, both open and closed-ended, that aimed to delve deeper into understanding the crisis of hazardous air conditions in Delhi. The respondents were primarily the native residents of Delhi, and their participation was fully voluntary.
1. According to you, which of the following is primarily responsible for air pollution in Delhi?

The respondents opined that vehicular pollution and stubble burning are the leading causes of air pollution, followed by industrial emissions and other factors, like burning of firecrackers during festive months, waste production etc.
2. Do you think overpopulation is a concern with regard to the problem of air pollution in Delhi?

An overwhelming 94% of the respondents held the view that overpopulation is exacerbating the problem of air pollution. With Delhi’s inadequate infrastructure, it intensifies the demands for energy, housing, and transport systems.
3. Are you aware of the government initiatives aimed at reducing Air pollution in Delhi?

Around three-fourths of the respondents are aware of the mitigatory measures, while the remaining 30% are yet untouched by the government’s efforts.
4.How much would you rate the effectiveness of these pollution control measures of the government, on a scale of 1-5?

A significant majority of the respondents rated the effectiveness of government measures as either 2 or 3 out of 5.This shows that there is a general dissatisfaction with the government schemes, possibly due to the gaps in the implementation.
5. Have you heard about the Air- Quality Index?

The fact that 88% of the respondents are familiar with the term "Air Quality Index" underscores the gravity of the problem and the growing environmental consciousness among the residents.
6. Have you or any of your family members ever suffered from an illness specifically due to air pollution?

The survey reveals that over 50% of the respondents suffered health ailments due to air pollution, underlining the potentially devastating impact on people’s well-being.
7. List down some government policies that you are aware of in the direction of combating air pollution. How far are those successful?
(a) Odd- even policy
(b) GRAP
(c) Ban on the usage of vehicles with lifespan exceeding 15 years
(d) Promotion of CNG vehicles
(e) Promotion of afforestation
While policies like afforestation and transition to CNG have been praised, more than the majority of respondents believe that policies like odd-even or bans on firecrackers are superficial, and lack effective implementation.
8.Have you personally adopted any measures at your level to deal with the crisis of air pollution?

There is an apparent hypocrisy when it comes to making individual efforts to curb air pollution. While residents recognize its severe impact, they consider it solely the government’s responsibility to address the issue.
9. What suggestions do you think would help the government to improve air quality policies and measures in Delhi?
(a) Develop sustainable urban planning systems and reducing population density in the region.
(b) Ban on firecrackers throughout the year.
(c) Development of green belts.
(d) Enforce stricter emission norms for vehicles and industries.
(e) Promotion of public transport systems.
(f) Focus on inter- state cooperation to check on practices like stubble burning.
AIR POLLUTION IN DELHI: SOURCES AND TRENDS
One of the important indicators of measuring air pollution is the air quality index. Lower the AQI, the better the air quality and vice- versa. On a standard note, AQI below 200 is considered moderate.
1. The air quality levels have fluctuated greatly between 2018-2023. However, out of a total of 365 days, only 189 days, on an average, had moderate air quality. This signifies the fact that for the rest half of the year, the air quality in the national capital deteriorated at alarming levels, owing to anthropogenic activities.
2. In the last few years, 2020 was a remarkable year in terms of improved air quality. This can be attributed wholly to the Covid-19 and the lock down effect which brought everything to a halt. This signifies the far reaching impact that can be made by effectively controlling anthropogenic activities, be it vehicular and industrial emissions or the construction work.

3. In 2024, Air pollution in Delhi showed rapid fluctuation in AQI from ranging above 300 in January, 50-100 in monsoons to 400-500 in the last months⁴. The peak was due to stubble burning and festive emissions even after the ban in the national capital ,while the lowest was justified by the monsoon rains. The other primary sources which contributed to the air pollution being the vehicle emission, pollutants from neighbourhood states, and industrial pollution other dust particles.
The chart below implies the same in brief:

ADVERSE EFFECTS ON HUMAN HEALTH AND ENVIRONMENT
The frequent symptoms people are experiencing due to the severe air pollution especially in the NCR are ocular irritation, coughing, and mild respiratory difficulties. But this is just the tip of the iceberg. More deadly diseases are brimming as people living in highly polluted areas are more prone to chronic diseases and decreased life expectancy. According to a report by WHO almost 99% of the population are living in areas with air quality index worse than deemed breathable⁵. Air pollution also has adverse impacts on the environment harming it in irreversible and dicey ways. These toxic pollutants affect Flora and Fauna who are silent bearers of their decreasing standard of health and life.
IMPACT ON HUMAN HEALTH –
1. Cardiovascular diseases – Fine particles in the air accumulate in the blood vessels, block them and increase the risk of cardiovascular diseases. They also affect an individual's blood pressure, and the buildup of nitrogen oxides can elevate the risk of hemorrhagic stroke.
2. Cancer – Numerous studies have come to analyse that exposure to air Pollution increases the risk of breast, lung, colorectal and prostate cancer. According to a study by the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences, Exposure to gasoline can cause leukemia and non- Hodgkin’s Lymphoma.
3. Respiratory diseases – A study conducted by the NIH found out the role of Air pollutants in respiratory morbidity. Higher levels of PM2.5 and PM10 were connected with higher numbers of visits to the hospital. The visits increased during winters due to environmental factors like cold air, less wind and rains settling the pollutant particles⁶.
4. For children – Breathing PM 2.5 and PM 10 may affect the brain’s development and is associated with an increased risk of cerebral palsy in them. A study by PubMed and National Library of Medicine showed correlation between air pollutants and development of the Attention Deficit Hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) in children. For the senior citizens, inhaling pollutants increases the risk of dementia and other neurological disorders.
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT
1. Acid rain- Formed mainly by nitrogen oxides and sulfur oxides, acid rain damages trees, acidifies water bodies making it unsuitable for aquatic wildlife while accelerating eutrophication.
2. Depletion of ozone layer and global warming – CFCs, HCFCs and Halons destroy the ozone layer in our Stratosphere. Depletion of ozone increases UV rays reaching the earth which harms crop yields. A study found that India’s annual wheat yields declined by 14.18% between 2008 and 2012 due to air pollution from ground level ozone⁷. Other GHGs like CO2 and Methane traps the sun’s heat to increase the temperature of the earth. This hampers our nature’s fine balance and damages the ecosystem.
3. Flora- Flora usually acts as carbon and pollutant sinks and helps sustain healthy levels of AQI. Dangerous levels of AQI affect the growth and longevity of plants. Gases like O3, SO2 and NO2 reduce the absorption capacity of photosynthesis, block the spores of the leaves and interfere with its functions. Different types of trees in Delhi, become resistant to the airborne pollutants in varying degrees. Such resistance can be proved through measuring PSMs ( Plant Secondary Metabolites ) which include phenols, alkaloids etc. For example- A rise in phenols and alkaloids could be seen in the M.Koenigii species in Delhi.
4. Fauna- Increased exposure to air pollutants can cause problems like vomiting, loss of hunger, coughing, sneezing or inflammation. Certain breeds like BIB (breathing impaired breeds) and those with short nasal passage like Pugs, Bulldogs and Shih Tzus are particularly vulnerable to these air pollutants. Among animals, the strays are the worst hit as they rarely get any medical intervention for these symptoms. Prolonged inhalation in the contaminated air can also contribute to cardiac arrests and other fatal conditions in these animals.
AIR POLLUTION POLICIES: ASSESSMENT AND GAPS
PARAMETERS | NCAP (National Clean Air Programme) | GRAP (Graded Action Response Plan) |
Year of Initiation | 2019 | 2017 |
Executing Organization | Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change (MoEFCC) | Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) |
Area of Operation | It covers over 122 non-attainment cities, across 21 states and 2 Union Territories. | It focuses on Delhi and the National Capital Region. |
Aim | To create a long-term, sustainable framework to reduce PM 2.5 levels by 2024 as compared to 2017. | Focuses on immediate and emergency protocols for the management of sudden spikes in air pollution. |
Major Focus | Long term air pollution reduction strategies. | Short term air pollution based on Graded Action Plans. |
Approach | Proactive and pragmatic - it focuses on systematic pollution reduction. | Reactive - It is enacted based on real time air quality data. |
Sources of Pollution | Broader focus on industries, transport, biomass burning and overall Urban planning. | Focus on local sources of air pollution such as vehicular emissions, construction, dust, firecrackers. |
Key measures | Establishment of air information and technology assessment cells, improving monitoring networks, industrial pollution control⁹. | Water sprinkling, mechanised road cleaning, various restrictions on vehicles, industries as well as construction work¹⁰. |
Shortcomings | 1. Overemphasis on PM10 rather than PM2.5. 2. Lack of transparency in data. 3. Inadequate action against industrial pollution 4. Poor fund allocation. 5. State Pollution Control Boards Lack inter state coordination. | 1. GRAP activates at actual PM2.5 and PM10 levels rather than predictions, liming its ability to proactively prevent pollution events. 2. Lack of coordination among NCR states. 3. Orders are often executed after pollution spikes because action by multiple departments is delayed under GRAP. 4. Fundamentally, views air pollution as a local issue instead of a cross border problem. 5. GRAP falls to fully utilize the real time air monitoring systems it has developed. |
Future Recommendations | 1. A multi-sector clean air action plan is required which is both federal and national in nature. 2. Several strategies related to industry,power plants, waste management, and clean fuels require greater support from the Central government. 3. Redirection of funds from dust control to emission-spewing combustion sources such as industries or transportations. 4. Expanding the area of operation to even small towns, villages and suburban areas which require common infrastructure¹¹. | 1. Delhi should transition from a reaction based approach to a forecast-based approach to reduce pollution levels. 2. Utilization of social media for communication and proper coordination amongst the public. 3. Implement stricter monitoring and regulatory action on industries and power plants contributing to air pollution¹². |
CASE STUDY: CHINA’S APPROACH TO AIR POLLUTION AND LESSONS FOR DELHI
Why Beijing?
Beijing's achievement in reducing extreme air pollution makes it a good example for Delhi, which deals with comparable issues including fast urbanization, industrial emissions, and seasonal agricultural pollution. Geographic restrictions cause both towns to suffer from air stagnation; historically, coal energy has been their main source. Given these parallels, Beijing's strategy provides important fresh ideas for Delhi's air pollution control.
Beijing’s Strategy: Aggressive, Multi-Sectoral, and Coordinated Policy Interventions
Strict rules, modern technology, and regional cooperation constituted Beijing's air pollution control's foundation. The success of interim pollution reduction policies shown by the 2008 Olympics resulted in the 2013 Clean Air Action Plan, which presents long-term remedies.–
1. Beijing phased down coal-fired power stations by 2017 and replaced natural gas and greener substitutes via subsidies. Delhi has started similar initiatives but must increase the acceptance of sustainable energy especially in relation to winter pollution surges¹³.
2. Control of vehicle emissions: Beijing's car pollution was much lowered by tight emission rules, traffic limitations, and a well-developed public transportation system. To be more successful Delhi's odd-even system requires more robust enforcement and coordination with public transportation.
3. High-emission Beijing industries were moved or obliged to use contemporary emissions control technologies. Although NCR's strong industrial presence makes industrial decentralisation more difficult for Delhi, a gradual relocation or upgrading plan could be a workable solution.
Managing Agricultural Pollution: Sustainable Practices
Beijing penalized stubble burning in order to address agricultural pollution, then pushed mulching, composting, and biofuel using subsidies. Delhi, which experiences stubble burning in surrounding states, has to take a similar stance combining fines with financial support for sustainable options and enhancing cooperation with Punjab and Haryana.
Monitoring and Public Engagement
Beijing greatly funded public education programs, real-time air quality monitoring, and data transparency, so increasing awareness and accountability. By extending Delhi's monitoring system and raising public participation, the city may help to foster shared responsibility for improving the air quality.
Analysis

Beijing's policies over five years produced a 35% reduction in PM2.5 levels, therefore proving the worth of multi-sectoral projects. Still, the plan required significant financial outlay and was backed by a centralized government, which Delhi's scattered administrative system could find more challenging to implement. Beijing's industrial migration also highlights the need for a regionally balanced strategy since it presents questions regarding pollution displacement¹⁴.
Translating Beijing's lessons for Delhi
The gains in Beijing's air quality underline the need for rigorous policy execution, financial incentives, and public participation. Delhi has to modify these approaches to fit its socio-political setting by giving cleaner energy top priority, enhancing public transportation, and encouraging regional cooperation. Sustained improvement in air quality will also depend on long-term actions including green belts and pollution management during severe storms.
RECOMMENDATIONS
A dual approach strategy can be adopted, one focusing on the government and another on the masses .
1. For the government, a unidirectional approach, such as ban over stubble burning alone, would not work. All other sources have to be dealt simultaneously, especially the chronic ones, in a concrete manner. For industrial pollution, medium and small scale air purification towers have been springing up in various cities. This can be effective but a better alternative could be the promotion of incentive- driven alternative fuels, such as natural gas.
2. People usually respond to incentives. This principle can also be applied to deal with vehicular emissions, another major contributing factor. The government can work on the development of extensive public transport systems such as the electric buses, which is still inadequate in terms of demand. Furthermore, incentives such as tax concessions upto a certain limit can be a lucrative option. It may seem that it will put substantial financial burden before the government but ultimately, net benefits would be in favour, considering the savings on the environmental costs in the long term. The realisation of all of these measures would require Centre- State cooperation and even with the neighbouring states. After all, the pollutants don’t respect the state boundaries.
3. Finally, air quality and pollution are people’s issues that cannot be resolved without engagement and cooperation from the people. So, increased awareness and advisories like staying indoors, etc. can be helpful. This can be achieved through the installation of robust air quality monitoring stations and showcasing the results to the general public through government websites, social media platforms and newspapers. This will bring transparency and sensitize the masses about the depth of the issue.
CONCLUSION
The alarming levels of air pollution in Delhi are more than just a seasonal concern; they represent a pressing environmental and public health crisis that, if left unmanaged, would pose a serious and irreversible threat to the environment as well as human health. The existing provisions to deal with the issue are somewhat inadequate, hence there is a pressing need for a comprehensive, coordinated, and rigorous multi-sectoral approach that is sustained over the long term, similar to the measures implemented in Beijing. Furthermore, it is essential to engage and educate the grassroots population encouraging them to take steps at the micro level. As the survey findings also indicate that heightened awareness of the issue does not necessarily translates to mitigatory measures.
Image Credits: The Atlantic
CONTRIBUTORS
Shagun Singh
Research Head, NITI
Shreya Raj
Senior Executive , NITI
Aditi Singh
Junior Executive, NITI
Anwesha Sharma
Junior Executive, NITI
Parag Saharan
Junior Executive, NITI
Prakreet Kashyap
Junior Executive, NITI
Soumay Rai Gupta
Junior Executive, NITI
REFERENCES
2. Desk, I. T. I. (2024, November 15). Delhi air pollution: Is Delhi now the world's most polluted city? India Today.
https://www.indiatoday.in/information/story/delhi-most-polluted-city-in-world-2633 726-2024-11-15%0Ahttps://www.indiatoday.in/information/story/delhi-most-pollute d-city-in-world-2633726-2024-11-15
3. Goswami, S. (2016, November 6). Delhi’s worst smog yet wakes up govt, emergency measures announced. Hindustan Times.
http://www.hindustantimes.com/delhi/delhi-sees-season-s-worst-air-quality-kejriw al-announces-emergency-steps/story-J11rGcyCdk2wn6T4jqxG2O.html
4. Express Web Desk. (1969, December 31). Delhi NCR Pollution Highlights: AQI ‘very poor’, vehicular emissions top contributor in Delhi. The Indian Express. https://indianexpress.com/article/cities/delhi/delhi-ncr-pollution-today-live-updates -delhis-air-quality-remains-very-poor-for-7th-consecutive-day-9653829 /
5. Pollution Data Portal , World Health Organization
6. Dutta, A., & Jinsart, W. (2022b). Air pollution in Delhi, India: It’s status and association with respiratory diseases. PLoS ONE, 17(9), e0274444. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0274444
7. Sharmila Vaidyanathan,(2024) “Rising air pollution impacts India’s crop yields And food security”
https://india.mongabay.com/2024/01/rising-air-pollution-impacts-indias-crop-yield s-and-food-security/
8. Lahiri, M., & Krishna, K. (2023). Effect of air pollution on plant secondary metabolites in selected trees of Delhi. Environmental Quality Management, 33(3), 399–409. https://doi.org/10.1002/tqem.22130
9. CREA – Centre for Research on Energy and Clean Air. (2025b, January 6). Tracing the Hazy Air 2024: Progress Report on National Clean Air Programme (NCAP) – Centre for Research on Energy and Clean Air. Centre for Research on Energy and Clean Air.
https://energyandcleanair.org/publication/tracing-the-hazy-air-2024-progress-repo rt-on-national-clean-air-programme-ncap/
10.Khan, A., Suryanarayanan, U., Ganguly, T., & Ganesan, K. (2022). Improving Air Quality Management through Forecasts: A Case Study of Delhi’s Air Pollution of Winter 2021. In Issue Brief.
https://www.ceew.in/sites/default/files/ceew-research-on-air-quality-management delhi-winter-pollution-case-study-2021.pdf
11. National Clean Air Programme: an agenda for reform. (n.d.).
12.Khan, A., Suryanarayanan, U., Ganguly, T., & Ganesan, K. (2022). Improving Air Quality Management through Forecasts: A Case Study of Delhi’s Air Pollution of Winter 2021. In Issue Brief.
https://www.ceew.in/sites/default/files/ceew-research-on-air-quality-management delhi-winter-pollution-case-study-2021.pdf
13.Beijing’s battle to clean up its air. (n.d.-b). UN Environment.
https://www.unep.org/interactive/beat-air-pollution/ , A review of 20 Years’ Air Pollution Control in Beijing. (n.d.). UNEP - UN Environment Programme. https://www.unep.org/resources/report/review-20-years-air-pollution-control-beijin g
14.Huang, L. (2023, November 20). How climate change complicates China’s ‘battle for blue skies.’ Dialogue Earth.



Comments