top of page

DUSU Elections: Decline in Student voter turnout

Nov 5, 2024
12 min read

Updated: Jan 11, 2025



INTRODUCTION  

The Delhi University Students' Union (DUSU) plays a pivotal role in shaping the political landscape of student representation in India. As a critical platform for voicing student concerns and aspirations, DUSU elections not only empower the student body but also serve as a microcosm of broader democratic processes in the country. However, recent elections have witnessed a troubling decline in voter turnout, raising questions about the engagement and relevance of the student union.


This research report aims to investigate the alarming drop in voter participation, particularly the significant decrease to 32.8% in the 2024 elections, a stark contrast to the 44.5% turnout recorded in 2018¹. To achieve this, a mixed-methods approach was employed, combining quantitative data from surveys and historical election trends with qualitative insights from group discussions among students. 


The decline in voter turnout highlights the pressing need to explore the underlying reasons behind this disengagement. Factors such as candidate disconnect, concerns about hooliganism, and a lack of awareness regarding election norms may contribute to students' disillusionment with the electoral process. Understanding these issues is crucial for restoring faith in the democratic principles that DUSU represents. Addressing these challenges is essential to revitalizing student participation and ensuring that DUSU remains a relevant and effective voice for the student community. 



METHODOLOGY  

In order to progress with the report, a mixed methodology was used in which both quantitative and qualitative methods of analysis were incorporated. The quantitative aspect, clearly presented through graphs and diagrams, helps to understand the trends and patterns– such as voter’s turnout over the years, awareness of the Lyngdoh Committee Guidelines among the students, etc. While the Qualitative aspects try to focus the glance on deeper questions like the reasons for not turning up on the D-day, criteria for voting the candidates, and ways to enhance the overall participation of students. 


Further, both primary and secondary sources of data collection were employed. The primary sources include a survey done through an online questionnaire. This was circulated throughout the university campus – North, South and Off, respectively, with a sample size of 250 respondents. Besides the survey, a group discussion was also organized in which close to 50 students participated and provided their insights about the same, helping to obtain a wider perspective. In secondary sources, newspaper articles, committee reports, legal journals, etc. have been used. 



HISTORICAL OVERVIEW AND PAST FIVE YEAR TRENDS  

DUSU, a student body, has its roots back in the 1940s when the first election took place in 1954. Traditionally, as witnessed, there has been a tug- of-war battle between the representatives of the Akhil Bharatiya Vidyarthi Parishad (ABVP) and the National Students Union of India ( NSUI). However, it does not mean that other parties have not been given space to voice their concerns. Over a period of time, the diversity among the choice of DUSU representatives have increased, leading to the presence of parties like the All India Students’ Association (AISA), the Students Federation of India (SFI), the Democratic Students’ Organization (DISHA), although these remain on margins in terms of vote shares. 

Graph 1- Percentage of Voter Turnout over the years

Source- Author


Turnout percentage from 2017 to 2024. 

  • As the graph shows, in 2017, a remarkable 42.8% of the voters turned up on the day of voting².

  • The year 2018 again witnessed an outstanding voter turnout of 44.5%. In fact, this was the highest voter turnout in the past 11 years by then³.

  • This voting percentage suffered a setback in 2019 when it dropped to 39%⁴.

  • The next two years, 2020 and 2021,saw no elections as the entire globe was battling with the COVID-19 pandemic. Due to this, the academic year faced disruptions, and as a result, 2022 union elections could not take place. 

  • The year 2023 witnessed the students’ union elections,and amazingly, the voter turnout happened to be almost 42%. This somewhat allayed the apprehensions that covid may have lasting implications on students’ participation.

  • The recent 2024 elections show a massive dip in turnout percentage to 32.8%. This has emerged as a major question before the entire student community of DU, including its representatives⁵.  This shall be looked at closely later. 

 


RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 

(A) Survey observation and Analysis 

  • As the chart illustrates, a substantial number of the respondents (62%) who participated in the survey did not turn up on the day of voting, somewhat similar to the overall figure. 

  • This lack of students’ engagement questions the relevance of students' union elections and hints at the need to address the limitations associated with it.


  • The majority of the respondents didn't turn up on the day of voting because of hooliganism and distrust of the candidates. Other significant factors included the suspension of classes, a general lack of interest in the elections, and challenges related to commuting. 

  • This is not a healthy indicator of democracy. The students are somewhat dissatisfied and therein a lack of trust has emerged in the current state of electoral affairs.


  • Among those who voted, party manifesto ( 45.1%) followed by ideology (35.2%) were the main deciding factors influencing their decision to choose their representatives. The fact that students went through the manifesto shows that they are not totally apathetic to the idea of elections. Besides, the element of ideology shows that they have beliefs in certain values and principles, and thus, they envision a student union inspired by those ideas.

  • However, a substantial 11% of the respondents voted as per the narratives around them, being driven by general opinions and influence. Other factors like caste and regional affiliation had minimal role to play.


  • When it comes to the awareness of the rules and regulations associated with the Lyngdoh Committee Guidelines, it can be observed that a considerable chunk of students, which is almost 49%, voted negatively.

  • This shows that students, to some extent, have a general disinterest which is not a promising sign for the very idea of democracy. This lack of awareness further facilitates unethical practices, rendering students more vulnerable to the influence of monetary incentives and coercive forces. 


  • The chart shows that the majority of the students feel that the candidates contesting the DUSU elections don't relate to the needs of the common students. 

  • It somewhat points to a growing divide between the aspirations of political candidates and the everyday concerns of the student body. However, 28% responded positively, while others are unsure.


  • The question about the recent HC judgment on the stay of election results elicited a mixed reaction. 

  • Although the majority of students favored the court's stance on halting the count, they accepted the fact that the issues of defacement of public property and excessive display of money and muscle power as raised in the petition were genuine. These students also believed that the rules and regulations were somewhat violated by the candidates to fulfill their ulterior motives.


(B) Group Discussion analysis 

Through the group discussion, an analysis was made for the possible reasons accounting for the low turnout, and the following picture emerged-


  • There was a popular belief that common students were not able to connect themselves with the candidates. They felt that the candidates contesting for union had their own political aspirations, whose fulfillment they were busy with. In order to achieve that, almost all forms of methods were employed, from campaigning ruthlessly to the display  of money and muscle power. The survey results also confirm this idea.


  • Some students pointed to the lack of diversity among the candidates and their manifestos. They argued that all the contesting candidates offered almost similar points in their manifesto, which made it difficult to make a choice among them. But this does not seem like  a satisfactory argument for abstaining from the vote, given the fact that the electoral process offers the option of NOTA, which can be used to express dissatisfaction with all of the candidates. 


  • Other possible reasons were the commute problem and holiday on the election days. However, this doesn't seem like a plausible idea considering that this has been in practice for decades, but the turnout touched the minimum percentage this year only.  


  • Some simply argued that they have general disinterest in political affairs. However, this cannot qualify as a justifiable reason for not turning up; the democratic spirit encourages everyone to  make their voices count in the decisions that would affect them.



DELHI HIGH COURT INTERVENTION 

The Delhi High Court is hearing a plea filed by a practicing advocate, Prashant Manchanda, who sought directions for the government to act against the defacement of public property by the candidates during the DUSU elections 2024. Prashant Manchanda argued that the candidates were spending recklessly in the campaigns and hence implied backing by the political parties. He further argued that printed posters, spray paints, and graffiti were used on a large scale despite the prohibition. There was an apparent display of money power, evident from the presence of luxury car convoys used in the campaign⁶.


All these instances are grave violations of the Lyngdoh Committee Guidelines, endorsed by the Supreme Court.


The Bench, led by acting Chief Justice Manmohan and Justice Tushar Rao Gadela, is hearing the matter. Following are the decisions till date: 

  • 26th September, 2024 – The bench allowed the conduct of the DUSU elections scheduled for 27th of September. However, the counting of votes was halted both for the DUSU and the college elections until the posters, graffiti, hoardings, spray paints, etc. were removed. The candidates were asked to restore the vandalized property and undo the losses suffered by MCD, Government departments and civic agencies. The court also criticized the university for its failure to ensure compliance with the election norms and regulations. Meanwhile, it also directed the university administration to safely secure the EVMs and ballot boxes until the issuance of further orders⁷.


  • 9th October, 2024 – While hearing a plea related to the students of Ramjas College and Law Faculty filed by advocate Prashant Manchanda against littering of campus area during campaigning, the court reiterated that the vote-counting process for the elections can only start once this clean-up process is completed. As evidence, the candidates must submit a status report along with photos⁸.


  • 21st October, 2024 –The Delhi High Court summoned the candidates allegedly linked with the defacement charge and asked them to appear before it in the next hearing. The court also instructed the university administration to notify the implicated candidates⁹.


  • 28th October, 2024 –The court interacted with several candidates, including the prospective ones, and asked them to file an affidavit once the entire cleanup is done. After this, it will allow the counting to be started. The court, as it said, did not want to punish "young impressionable minds" and instead gave them a chance to clean up the mess and restore the sanctity of the campus. Meanwhile, it has also asked the university to prepare a fresh report¹⁰.



LYNGDOH COMMITTEE GUIDELINES

The Lyngdoh Committee was constituted in December 2005 upon the order of the Supreme Court. Under the leadership of J.M. Lyngdoh, former Chief Election Commissioner, the committee was to examine the student union elections in educational institutions across India and recommend changes to them.


After examining the conditions, the committee submitted an extensive report to the Supreme Court, and the court mandated its recommendations to be followed in all university / college elections. The recommendations covered numerous aspects like the mode of elections, frequency and duration of election process, eligibility criteria for candidates, expenditure on election campaigning, code of conduct for both the candidates and the election administrators, and so on.


However, there are certain ambiguities in the Guidelines because of which the vision of reforming the student union elections positively cannot be fully realized-


  • Clause 6.6.1. The maximum permitted expenditure per candidate shall be Rs.5000/.

    • Loophole: According to the clause, the expenditure on election expenses cannot exceed Rs.5000. However, actual expenditure often surpasses the ceiling amount, with the indirect involvement of political parties in DUSU elections. Candidates often misspell their names, often by adding an extra alphabet in their names to escape any legal consequences. Therefore, the limit should be revised and strictly enforced.


  • Clause 6.7.9. During the election period the candidates may hold processions and/or public meetings, provided that such processions and/or public meetings do not, in any manner, disturb the classes and other academic and co curricular activities of the college/university. Further, such a procession/public meeting may not be held without the prior written permission of the college/university authority.

    • Loophole: In this clause, it  is mentioned that the candidates cannot disturb the routine workings of the institutions. But it is to our clear knowledge that this is not the case. The candidates in this case use their respective parties and their machinery for campaigning, as nothing is mentioned about the political parties. The candidates are not recognized by their parent parties to escape legal action. 


  • Clause 6.7.5. No candidate shall be permitted to make use of printed posters, printed pamphlets, or any other printed material for the purpose of canvassing. Candidates may only utilize hand–made posters for the purpose of canvassing, provided that such hand-made posters are procured within the expenditure limit.

    • Loophole: This provision can be effectively implemented in relatively smaller colleges, where the number of students is fewer. In larger colleges or universities like DU, it’s practically impossible to reach out to such a large number of voters across different campuses through hand made posters, and that too within the prescribed limit of Rs.5000 only. The committee could have allowed the usage of printed posters up to a certain limit in these cases.


  • Clause 6.7. This section comprehensively deals with the Code of Conduct for the candidates as well as election administrators. 

    • Loophole: There is no mention about the conduct of candidates while campaigning on social media, which has become a great platform for mobilizing the voters in contemporary times. For example, there has been no provision that addresses the spread of misinformation or hate speech on social media platforms.


( Note: All these clauses have been taken from Lyngdoh Committee Report¹¹.)



RECOMMENDATIONS 

  • Hooliganism and muscle power have emerged as a prominent problem with the DUSU. To tackle this, a permanent and independent election committee can be appointed. In fact, the Delhi High Court had also remarked that the university lacked moral authority in addressing these issues. An independent committee, exclusive of the university staff and officials, could take stern measures to maintain electoral integrity and bring accountability from the candidates. 

  • The Guidelines of the Lyngdoh Committee can be revised with rigid provisions, addressing the existing loopholes in order to make the electoral processes more efficient.

  • Further, debates among the DUSU candidates and hosting interviews about their vision and manifestos would help to sensitize the students about their representatives and make informed choices.

  • The stigma that politics is an evil affair needs to be broken through awareness campaigns by the university administration or respective college authorities. This will bring more suitable candidates on the floor, who are actually concerned with the needs of the student community and make the elections more competitive. For the voters also, it would imply diverse options.

  • One of the major issues for not casting the vote was dissatisfaction with the candidates. It's perfectly possible to have such circumstances, and democratic values do provide a scope for its manifestation through NOTA. Instead of silencing their voices, the voters must express their discontent through the endorsement of the NOTA option on the EVMs, as happened in the Indore constituency during the Lok Sabha Election. This outlet provides constructive feedback to the contesting candidates to find the underlying issues and address them.

  • Introducing an online system of nomination, or alternatively, hosting it in a public space, can also bring transparency and legitimacy, thus affirming voters' faith in the electoral process.



CONCLUSION 

The Delhi University Students Union, notwithstanding the limitations, holds immense importance in the political landscape of the country, and so its elections. This year's election was marked with an overwhelmingly low turnout. This silent outburst was the outcome of multiple factors, with the most important one being hooliganism and dissatisfaction. The Delhi High Court order on the stay of election results owing to the violation of Lyngdoh Committee Guidelines is a testimony of the deteriorating situation and a wake-up call for all the stakeholders.The authorities must realize their power and duty to ensure that electoral integrity is maintained, while the prospective candidates must realize the needs of common students and regulate their conduct, putting aside their personal ambitions. Finally, the voters must also realize that it's their democratic obligation to make their voices count. 


After all, DUSU is a student body that must reflect the will of students’ alone. The will of students should be chosen wisely, as they are also the future leaders, the embodiment of national aspiration in the coming tomorrow.


Image Credits: Karan Pareek


CONTRIBUTORS 

Shagun Singh 

Research Head, NITI


Shreya Raj 

Senior Executive, NITI 


Prakreet Kashyap

Junior Executive, NITI 


Soumay Rai Gupta 

Junior Executive, NITI 


Parag Saharan

Junior Executive, NITI 


Aditi Singh

Junior Executive, NITI 


Yashika Yadav

Junior Executive, NITI 

REFERENCES 

  1. Indian Express. (2024, November 1). Delhi University students’ union polls turnout dips; holiday on election day, HC defacement order likely factors. Indian Express. https://indianexpress.com/article/cities/delhi/delhi-university-students-union-polls-turnout-dips-holiday-on-election-day-hc-defacement-order-likely-factors-9592148/](https://indianexpress.com/article/cities/delhi/delhi-university-students-union-polls-turnout-dips-holiday-on-election-day-hc-defacement-order-likely-factors-9592148/

  2. Rajput, A. (2017, September 14). DUSU election 2017: NSUI deals ABVP a blow, wins top posts. Hindustan Times. https://www.hindustantimes.com/delhi-news/dusu-election-2017-nsui-returns-on-the-scene-leading-on-three-posts/story-0YUegtzkAmnqKRei1wmv4I.html 

  3. Ibrar, M., & India, T. O. (2018, September 13). At 44.5%, DUSU elections record highest voter count in 11 years. The Times of India. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/delhi/at-44-5-dusu-polls-record-highest-voter-count-in-11-years/articleshow/65789811.cms 

  4. India Today. (2019, September 13). DUSU polls record 39.90% voter turnout: Are the DU student elections an indicator of political weather? https://www.indiatoday.in/education-today/news/story/dusu-polls-record-39-90-voter-turnout-are-the-du-student-elections-an-indicator-of-political-weather-1598682-2019-09-13 

  5. TIMESOFINDIA.COM. (2023, August 24). Delhi: DUSU polls after 4 years, voting on Sept 23. The Times of India. https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/delhi/delhi-dusu-polls-after-4-years-voting-on-sept-23/articleshow/103033162.cms

  6. “Lacking moral authority and courage”: Delhi HC reprimands university over failure to discipline DUSU candidates. (n.d.). LawBeat. https://lawbeat.in/news-updates/lacking-moral-authority-and-courage-delhi-hc-reprimands-university-over-failure 

  7. Delhi HC allows DU to proceed with Student Union Polls, bars counting and declaration of results. (2024, September 26). ANI News. https://www.aninews.in/news/national/general-news/delhi-hc-allows-du-to-proceed-with-student-union-polls-bars-counting-and-declaration-of-results20240926173459/ 

  8. Indian Express. (2024, November 2). DUSU polls: Delhi High Court on vote counting, defacement of public property. Indian Express. https://indianexpress.com/article/cities/delhi/dusu-polls-delhi-high-court-vote-counting-defacement-public-property-9613294/ 

  9. DU elections: Delhi HC summons candidates over property defacement, says “No results be announced till cleanup done.” (2024, October 21). ANI News. https://www.aninews.in/news/national/general-news/du-elections-delhi-hc-summons-candidates-over-property-defacement-says-no-results-be-announced-till-cleanup-done20241021182311/ 

  10. Prasad, M., & Law, L. (2024, October 29). Live law. Live Law. https://www.livelaw.in/high-court/delhi-high-court/delhi-high-court-dusu-mutilate-walls-du-no-right-steps-for-beautifying-campus-273834 

  11. Ministry of Human Resource Development. (2006). Lyngdoh Committee report on recommendations for students' union elections. University Grants Commission. Retrieved from https://www.ugc.gov.in/oldpdf/students_pdf/lyngdoh_committeemhrd2712.pdf 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page