Inside The Mind Of A Chancellor: A Psychoanalytic Exploration of ANGELA MERKEL
Introduction
“We can do this.”, this was the response of Angela Merkel to one of the most chaotic times of her 16-year tenure as the Chancellor of Germany, which was the Refugee Crisis of 2015. This statement carried weight not only because of the scale of the crisis, but also because of the fact that it came from a leader who is generally known for her calculative, methodological and restrained approaches. Merkel wasn't the kind to rush, she observed, she waited for the circumstances to be clearer. Her background in science was a major reason why she mostly opted for a methodical approach while solving problems instead of dramatic speeches and hasty decisions which upheld the balance of public order. She was able to work across various ideological divisions which fueled her political longevity.
Though, could this restrained and cautious behaviour be considered as hesitation? Or even a weakness? Merkel’s patient approach helped her in many ways, but this exact approach sometimes made her appear hesitant or unwilling to take a clear decision. Her changing her decisions to adapt to the situation at times raised questions on how unwaveringly she maintained a particular ideology. Comparison between the way she handled the Eurozone crisis and COVID-19 aiming for stability and the Refugee Crisis revealing a more humanitarian aspect of her decision demonstrates the tension between caution and adaptation and raises public criticism.
The question arises, What do Merkel’s patterns of deliberation, consensus-building, risk avoidance and reliance on established institutions reveal about the psychology behind her leadership?
The Making of a Cautious Leader
Before Angela Merkel became one of Europe’s most influential political leaders, she had spent most of her life away from politics. Born in 1954, she grew up in East Germany, where political life was tightly regimented and personal agency existed only within narrow boundaries. She went on to study Physics at Leipzig University and spent more than a decade working as a research scientist, completing her doctorate in 1986 and continuing her scientific work until the political upheavals of 1989 drew her into politics.
This background matters for understanding the personality that later emerged in her political career. Merkel was not shaped by the usual path of political ambition from an early age. Her formative years were spent observing a highly controlled political system, then years of scientific research in which problems were approached with patience, evidence and careful examination. Even her entry into politics came at a moment of uncertainty, as the East German system was collapsing and Germany's own future remained unclear.
Her scientific training should not be treated as a direct explanation for her personality, but the resemblances between her professional background and the method that later defined her politics is hard to ignore. Physics demanded precision, patience and a willingness to work through a problem before arriving at an answer and she rarely appeared eager to reach a conclusion simply for the sake of appearing decisive. Instead, she has gradually developed a political style built around watching circumstances unfold before committing herself.
Her upbringing may have made stability particularly valuable, while her scientific training provided an environment in which careful analysis was more useful than immediate reaction. Combined with the negotiation-heavy nature of German coalition politics, these experiences laid the foundation for a leadership style that was restrained, patient and adaptable.
The Merkel who eventually emerged was therefore not simply cautious by nature. Her personality and her circumstances together produced a distinct way of handling uncertainty: observe first, understand the situation, preserve room to manoeuvre, and act only once circumstances demand it.
Technocratic Deliberation and Merkel
Merkel's cautious nature was most visible in how she made decisions. Rather than reacting immediately to a crisis, she typically let the situation develop, listened to different sides, and waited until its consequences became clearer. This habit eventually gave rise to the German expression "Merkeln" which is a term for her tendency to wait, observe and deliberate before taking a position.
The Eurozone crisis is one of the clearest examples. Merkel had to balance German concerns about financial responsibility against pressure to support countries facing severe economic difficulties. Her instinct seemed to be to keep as many options open as possible until a workable solution came into view, so the process involved prolonged negotiations and conditional measures rather than a swift commitment to any single fix. This was often criticised as slow, but it also stopped her from making decisions without weighing their wider consequences.
The 2011 decision to phase out nuclear power shows a different side of the same pattern. Merkel had previously supported nuclear energy, but after the Fukushima disaster in Japan she reversed course and announced the closure of Germany's remaining nuclear plants. Compared with her earlier stance, the decision was abrupt, yet it reflected her willingness to change direction once the evidence pointed to changed circumstances. Her caution, then, did not necessarily mean rigidity, it could also mean waiting until new information made a different decision necessary.
Her decision-making style was equally visible beyond major international crises. Merkel often let disagreements within her government and coalition play out before intervening directly, allowing competing interests to become clear rather than imposing one position on the others from the outset.
This makes "Merkel” more complicated than simply calling Merkel indecisive. Her tendency to delay could easily look like hesitation, but it also bought her time to weigh consequences and adjust her position. Her approach to decisions was less about avoiding them than about avoiding premature ones.
Consensus Over Ideology
Merkel's politics were never built around holding to one rigid ideology. Instead, she sought a middle ground between competing interests, an approach that mattered greatly in a political system where coalition government demanded constant negotiation and compromise. Rather than letting disagreements harden into permanent divisions, she typically worked to bring different sides towards a position that could actually function.
Her ability to work across political divides was central to her longevity. Over her sixteen years as Chancellor, she governed with different coalition partners, working with both the Social Democratic Party and the Free Democratic Party at various points despite significant differences from her own Christian Democratic Union. Doing so required her to adjust her positions and negotiate rather than insist on ideological consistency.
The same flexibility showed up within the CDU itself. Merkel often shifted the party towards positions more in step with changing public opinion, folding policies and ideas associated with her political opponents into the CDU's own programme and narrowing the ground available to rival parties.
This same tension ran through her major policy decisions. Her career held several moments where she changed course rather than defend an earlier position at all costs, showing a readiness to shift as circumstances shifted. Christian Schnee's assessment of Merkel's political decisions between 2005 and 2017 likewise centres on the tension between rigidity and flexibility, suggesting her adaptability was a recurring trait of her governing style rather than an occasional exception.
Yet constantly adapting to circumstances rather than shaping them can make a leader look like she is reacting to events instead of directing them.
Her critics questioned whether her pragmatism and taste for compromise came at the cost of a clear ideological direction, whether her flexibility reflected political skill or simply an unwillingness to take a firm stand. For Merkel, though, a stable and workable outcome seems to have mattered more than ideological purity: consensus did not mean the absence of principles so much as a way of making her principles politically achievable.
Risk Mitigation and Incrementalis
A major pattern in Merkel's leadership was her preference for reducing risk rather than resolving uncertainty through sudden action. She generally favoured gradual solutions, giving herself room to see how a situation developed before making a larger commitment. Timoshenkova describes minimal risk-taking and the avoidance of direct confrontation as central to Merkel's political strategy.
The 2011 nuclear phase-out is one of the clearest examples. Before the Fukushima disaster, Merkel had supported extending the operating lives of Germany's nuclear plants. The disaster changed the political landscape around nuclear energy almost overnight, and Merkel reversed her earlier position, announcing that Germany would phase out nuclear power entirely.
What matters about this decision is not only the policy itself but what it reveals about her decision-making: once the perceived risks changed, so did the decision.
The refugee crisis of 2015, however, sits at odds with this pattern. Merkel's decision to allow large numbers of refugees into Germany looked far more open and politically risky than the caution normally associated with her. Yet the aftermath showed that one bold decision did not mean she had abandoned her usual preference for control, instead her government went on to manage the consequences through European negotiations, border arrangements and domestic political measures.
The crisis also exposed an important distinction between avoiding risk and managing it. Merkel was willing to accept a risk when she judged that avoiding it would create a larger problem, so her behaviour cannot simply be labelled risk-averse. Rather, she seemed to weigh which form of uncertainty was more manageable.
COVID-19 brought out this same pattern in a very different setting. Merkel's government repeatedly adjusted restrictions and responses as scientific understanding of the virus evolved. Her approach was not to settle on one permanent decision at the outset of the crisis but to keep adapting as new information came in.
Across these crises, the pattern holds fairly steady. Merkel did not avoid risk altogether; she tried to manage it. Her incrementalism, which let her correct course when needed, became more than a policy preference, it became a way of maintaining control. Rather than solving every problem with one decisive move, she typically worked through problems by way of smaller adjustments.
Multilateral Frameworks and the Psychology of Stability
Merkel's preference for stability also showed in her reliance on multilateral institutions. Throughout her chancellorship, she leaned heavily on frameworks such as the European Union, NATO and wider international bodies.
Her approach to Russia illustrates this well. Merkel's relationship with Vladimir Putin was never simply one of friendship or hostility. Germany kept engaging with Russia even as relations grew more difficult, particularly after the Ukraine crisis, with diplomatic negotiation and European frameworks remaining her main tools. The Minsk process, for instance, reflected an attempt to manage conflict through negotiation rather than treat military confrontation as the only option.
The same logic ran through her approach to the European Union. During periods of crisis, Merkel generally preferred negotiation between member states over unilateral German action. Germany's influence within Europe was considerable, but she usually worked through European structures rather than treating German preferences as sufficient on their own.
For a leader whose political style depended so heavily on weighing consequences and limiting uncertainty, these institutions offered something especially valuable: predictability. They provided rules, alliances, negotiations and procedures through which disagreements could be managed rather than left to sudden political reaction.
This fits closely with the broader psychological pattern in Merkel's leadership. She seemed more at ease with uncertainty when a framework existed through which it could be controlled.
At the same time, this reliance on institutions carried its own limitations. Multilateral decision-making is inherently slower, since it depends on several actors reaching agreement. Merkel's preference for institutional stability could therefore sometimes reinforce the very hesitation for which she was criticised. Her leadership showed that stability and decisiveness are not always easy to achieve at once.
The Merkel Paradox: Strength or Indecision?
As we have seen, Merkel’s leadership presents a clear paradox. The qualities that contributed to her political success could also become the very reason for criticism against her. Her calculated approach allowed her to consider different consequences before acting, but when this process continued for a prolonged period, it could be perceived as hesitation. Similarly, her sensible behaviour allowed her to respond to changing circumstances, yet her willingness to adjust her position sometimes made it difficult to identify a consistent ideological direction.
Her preference for consensus created political stability and allowed her to work across competing interests. However, compromise also had its limitations. Attempts to accommodate different sides could produce decisions that avoided major conflict without fully satisfying any side. This tension between stability and decisiveness became one of the defining features of her leadership.
Yet, Merkel’s record suggests that describing her simply as an indecisive leader would be an oversimplification. What appears more significant is the process through which she reached decisions. Rather than committing immediately, she often kept different possibilities open until the circumstances became clearer. Once a direction became necessary, she generally acted within what she considered politically and institutionally possible. Her flexibility, therefore, did not necessarily indicate an absence of conviction. In several important situations, she demonstrated that she was capable of taking firm positions when she believed the circumstances required it.
This makes her leadership psychologically interesting. Merkel appeared to place considerable importance on stability, control and reducing uncertainty. Her scientific training, early experiences and political career provide context for this tendency, while her major political decisions show how it translated into practice. She often observed before acting, negotiated before confronting, adapted when circumstances changed and relied on established institutions when uncertainty could not be easily resolved.
The paradox, therefore, lies not in whether Merkel was cautious or decisive, but in how these qualities operated together. Her caution could prevent unnecessary risks and allow her to manage complicated situations patiently. At the same time, it could create delays or give the impression that she was responding to events rather than shaping them. Her pragmatism gave her room to adapt, but could also make her leadership appear less ideologically defined.
Ultimately, Merkel’s cautiousness cannot be understood simply as either a strength or a weakness. It was one of the central characteristics of her leadership, and its consequences depended greatly on the situation. The same patience that helped her navigate crises and maintain political stability could, under different circumstances, appear as hesitation.
The psychology behind Merkel’s leadership therefore seems to be less about avoiding change and more about controlling the way change takes place. Rather than choosing between complete stability and immediate transformation, she often searched for a position that preserved stability while leaving room for future adaptation. This is what makes the “Merkel paradox” significant, her greatest strength and her most persistent criticism emerged from the same underlying tendency which is a preference for caution, calculation and controlled change.
References
Blumenau, B. (2022). Keep calm and carry on! Angela Merkel and her chancellorship.
Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung. (n.d.). Angela Merkel als Regierungschefin und als Kanzlerkandidatin. Aus Politik und Zeitgeschichte.
Dasep, M. (2024). Angela Merkel’s leadership in Germany’s open door policy regarding the handling of the refugee crisis in Europe. Journal of Global Strategic Studies, 4(1), 72–87.
Federal Government of Germany. (n.d.). Angela Merkel: Federal Chancellor 2005–2021.
Forsberg, T. (2016). From Ostpolitik to “Frostpolitik”? Merkel, Putin and German foreign policy towards Russia. International Affairs, 92(1), 21–42. https://doi.org/10.1111/1468-2346.12505
Gaskarth, J., & Oppermann, K. (2021). Clashing traditions: German foreign policy in a new era. International Studies Perspectives, 22(1), 84–105. https://doi.org/10.1093/isp/ekz017
German Bundestag. (n.d.). Angela Merkel – Biography.
Helms, L., & van Esch, F. (2017). Turning structural weakness into personal strength: Angela Merkel and the politics of leadership capital in Germany. In The Oxford handbook of German politics. Oxford University Press.
Helms, L., van Esch, F., & Crawford, B. (2018). Merkel III: From committed pragmatist to “conviction leader”? German Politics, 27(3), 350–370. https://doi.org/10.1080/09644008.2018.1462340
Kuhlmann, S., et al. (2022). Technocratic decision-making in times of crisis? The use of data for scientific policy advice in Germany’s COVID-19 management. Policy Sciences. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11115-022-00635-8
Nai, A., & Maier, J. (2019). Can anyone be objective about Donald Trump? Assessing the personality of political figures. Journal of Elections, Public Opinion and Parties. https://doi.org/10.1080/17457289.2019.1632318
Schnee, C. (2019). Sticking to her guns or going with the flow: Assessing rigidity and flexibility in Angela Merkel’s political decision making. German Politics and Society, 37(1), 24–46. https://doi.org/10.3167/gps.2019.370102
Schnee, C. (2020). Exploring the strategy of government: A statecraft assessment of Angela Merkel’s chancellorship from 2005 to 2017. Politics, 40(3), 295–312. https://doi.org/10.1177/0263395719881035
Timoshenkova, E. P. (2022). Angela Merkel’s leadership lessons: The secret of political longevity (2013–2021). Herald of the Russian Academy of Sciences, 92(Suppl. 2), S119–S125. https://doi.org/10.1134/S1019331622080111
Content by:
Havisha Rajpal
Prabhgun Kaur
Edited by: Sharanya Verma


Comments