Marriage in India: Navigating Consent and Conjugal Rights

The Indian government considers prosecuting a man for raping his wife to be an “excessively harsh” and a “disproportionate” step, as per the 49-page affidavit that was submitted to the Supreme Court. The entanglement of marital rape in legal, social, historical, and cultural aspects makes it a herculean task for any authoritative entity within the Indian political and legal apparatus to take a decisive and bold step towards its criminalisation, unlike nations like the U.S., Canada, and more such countries, who have declared it a crime.
At present in India, marital rape is excluded from the ambit of any other “normal rape case," the only reason being that the former is forceful sex ‘within the institution of marriage,’ which in itself has been held sacred and dear in Indian society since time and immemorial, and there has been a continuous collective effort to stigmatise anything that defiles the sacrosanct nature of marriage. At present, marital rape comes under the purview of domestic violence recognised under the 2005 Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act. This Act enables women to seek legal remedies for marital rape, offering an avenue for availing themselves of legal separation from an abusive spouse. However, these mechanisms fail to capture the gravity of this issue. The United Nations has also urged countries, including India, to address the legalities surrounding marital rape seriously since “homes are one of the most dangerous places for women." This statement by the UN highlights how a woman is the most vulnerable in her immediate surroundings, and the lack of robust laws for issues like these only amplifies this vulnerability further.
In a recent government survey, it was found that one in every 25 women has been assaulted by their husbands, and 10-15% of women have been subjected to some form of sexual violence by their spouses. It is Section 375 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) that addresses the issue of rape. It also has an exception clause that states that “sexual intercourse by a man with his wife, the wife not being under 15 years of age, is not rape” and therefore brings us back to the aforementioned point regarding the legal exclusion of marital rape from rape-centric laws, which remains one among the many problematic areas of this issue, but not the only one since it is riddled with a lot of discrepancies. Section 376 of the IPC outlines the punishment for rape, stipulating that a rapist should face imprisonment for a term not less than 7 years, extendable to life imprisonment, or a term up to 10 years, along with a fine. However, if the victim is the husband’s wife and is not below 12 years of age, the punishment is reduced to imprisonment for up to 2 years or a fine, or both.
It brings out the fact that the legal stance on marital rape hinges on the age of the wife, which is at loggerheads with the right to live with dignity enshrined in Article 21 of the Indian Constitution. However, this is not the end of the story, as Within the age provisions mentioned in the IPC, more intricacies follow. Minor marriages are considered void as per our law, which rules out the above-stated possibilities based on different age brackets below 21 years (legal age for marriage), but religious communities like that of Islam have different ways of defining minor age, questioning the validity of the entire provision of sections 375 and 376 of the IPC and calls for elucidation of the same. The POCSO act is yet another legality that comes in clash with these sections since, as per the former, any sexual assault with a girl who is under 18 years of age needs to be treated as a POCSO case and not a rape one.
Over the years, there have been different interpretations and verdicts on this issue. In 2012, a committee constituted under J.S. Verma, a retired judge of the Supreme Court, recommended the criminalisation of marital rape. The Verma committee argued that the notion of forceful sex within the institution of marriage not being capable enough to be termed ‘rape’ stemmed from the archaic and patriarchal notion of married women being the property of their husbands and irrevocably consenting to the latter’s sexual needs. The committee recommended the exception clause be deleted. Yet, the Criminal Law (Amendment) Bill, 2012 (drafted in the aftermath of the Verma Commission report), did not have any provision to criminalise marital rape. It reasoned that the “entire family system will be under great stress and the committee may perhaps be doing more injustice.” The court has also often passed a verdict stating that 'denial of sex by a spouse amounts to cruelty’ which results in making things worse in reality, as on the one hand, women who are already living in the absence of adequate legal shields to protect them from heinous crimes like rape become more susceptible to harm, and on the other hand, husbands get the leeway to misuse the institution of marriage to satiate their sexual desires even if need be.
Marital rape continues to remain one of those few issues in society that is always brushed under the rug for being a ‘Western concept’ that can’t be applied to the Indian ‘Sanskriti’ and value system because all it does is destabilise the family structure and corrupt the extremely pure idea of marriage. The manifold facets of marital rape have often resulted in the decision-making bodies of our country washing their hands off of bringing about a drastic change in the constitution that could empower women to make their lives better, who unfortunately cease to take a stand for themselves today and continue to indulge in self-blame for every form of harassment that has taken place with them post marriage.
Image Credits: The Indian Express
Content by Safia Dutt (safia01486@gmail.com)
Edited by Yash Raj ( ryash5999@gmail.com)


Comments