top of page

The Paradox of Meritocracy in India

Feb 3
4 min read

Updated: Feb 5

Dungara Ram Choudhary-JEE 2002 topper, IIT Kanpur graduate, now working in Oracle- is seen as the epitome of success in entrance exam of JEE. His father sold his land just to afford the coaching fees . But imagine what if the story was another way if he might not have cleared the exam.  What a big financial distress it would have been for his father, who gave his entire asset, just to fulfill his child's IIT dream. Sadly, not all stories have such endings.

 

A SYSTEM BASED ON FAIRNESS-IN THEORY ONLY

 Entrance exams ranging from JEE to CUET had just one motive: to identify the most capable students in the backdrop of vast population without any discrimination, the logic was simple- a test which rewards hardwork,  creating a ladder to success, which anyone based on talent and hardwork can climb, but the lived reality is in sharp contrast with this ideal. This is where the coaching industry creates an uneven playing field . Yes, a massive coaching industry, estimated to be worth around ₹ 65,000 to 70,000 crore in 2026, has grown around these exams (Sharma & Sharma, 2026).

 

WHEN MONEY DECIDES MERIT 

Even elite institutions like the Indian Institutes of Technology (IITs) acknowledge that most successful candidates have participated in coaching — some estimates suggest around 95 % of students clearing JEE-Advanced had joined coaching classes (Contributors to Wikimedia projects,n.d.). This shows that these exams have evolved in contests of preparation infrastructure rather than pure academic merit.

 

 According to the government’s Comprehensive Modular Survey (CMS) 2025, nearly one in three school students in India now takes private coaching. This highlights about the growing perception that normal schooling cannot prepare child for competitive exams which are essential.

 Some coaching institutes report high qualification rates compared with national averages; for example, one Kota institute reported nearly 65.8% of its students qualified JEE Advanced 2025 — far above the overall national qualification rate(The Economic Times,2025). This shows how coaching system dramatically tilt outcomes in favor of those enrolled, reinforcing inequality.

 This creates an implicit advantage for wealthier families who can afford these coaching packages, which makes success in a supposedly merit-based exam correlate strongly with access to paid preparation, the exam no longer only measures pure academic ability or potential — it also measures access to resources.

 

 

FROM PAPER LEAKS TO DIGITAL GLITCHES

 

Even this all is not enough, the exam administration in India has faced repeated high visibility failures in recent years from localized paper leaks to large scale controversies, that forced cancellations and re examinations.

 

During the SSC phase 13 exams in July-August, many students reported several technical failures, including system crashes increasing computer terminals, biometric authentication malfunctioning, improper centre allocation, abrupt cancellations without prior communications, etc (Indian Express, 2025). Such disruptions created confusion and distress, forcing students to travel, long distances and bear additional financial burden.

 

Also, in SSC CGL Tier 1 exam cycle held between September 12–26, nearly 10,000 candidate complaints were lodged about technical issues, and about 2,000 candidates reported problems significant enough to warrant a re-exam. Also the result of 22 NEET PG candidates was cancelled in 2025 due to malpractices allegations (Times of India, 2025). While the number may appear small compared to total applicants, it reveals serious gaps in exam security and monitoring mechanisms.

 

 This has triggered political criticism opposition leaders stated that “around 85 lakh students” were affected by mismanagement in government recruitment and competitive exams in 2025 (PTI & PTI, 2025). It was not merely a data; it represented millions of disrupted academic futures. In December 2025, a parliamentary committee openly flagged these issues, saying such mishaps undermine confidence in NTA's ability to conduct fair exams.

 

MAKING MERIT MEANINGFUL AGAIN

 

Finally, the government entrance examinations in India were envisioned as an instrument of educational equality, but repeated mishaps in exam conduct and coaching dependency have diluted this promise. But all is not yet over. If policymakers combine transparent accountability and also reduce coaching dependency by aligning exams closely with school curricular and providing free high quality official study material. So, with accountable governance, transparent exams conduct and inclusive support systems, entrance exams can once again become genuine instruments of social mobility and trust.


Content by: Avisha Mehta


Edited by: Ashutosh Koul


References:

 

1.Sharma, M., & Sharma, M. (2026, January 24). Coaching industry in India 2026: Size, growth, challenges, forecast. Businesses Base. https://share.google/9U68RT2KKTtKGyT0R

 

2.Contributors to Wikimedia projects. (2026, January 25). Indian Institutes of Technology. Wikipedia. https://share.google/FqqeVIcHOnIygWV5Q

 

3.Education, E. (2025b, April 22). Kota coaching institute claims over 65 per cent of its students qualified for JEE Advanced 2025. ETEducation.com. https://share.google/ZxkGXf4Gy6eJe87lj

 

4.Express News Service. (2025, August 2). Cancellations, glitches, wrong exam centre: Here’s why SSC aspirants are protesting in Delhi. The Indian Express. https://share.google/cfY2w2EgOwWQ4bs8J

 

5.Education, T. (2025, October 11). NEET PG result cancelled: 22 aspirants disqualified by NBEMS for malpractice in exams from 2021-2025. The Times of India. https://share.google/maD2Ao2y9PhYQvIPX

 

6.PTI, & PTI. (2025, March 13). Future of 85 lakh children in six states at risk: Rahul Gandhi slams BJP over exam paper leaks. Deccan Herald. https://share.google/CWFdbtRBFJ9h4YvHf

 

 

 

Recent Posts

See All
THE BURDEN OF BEING SAFE

“Without community, there is no liberation, only the most vulnerable and temporary armistice between an individual and her oppression.” — Audre Lorde INTRODUCTION Don’t go out alone. Don’t go out afte

 
 
 
UNDER THE RUBBLE: THE SATYA NIKETAN TRAGEDY

Every year, the narrow lanes of Delhi swell with thousands of young students, carrying nothing but heavy luggage and even heavier dreams of securing a position at Delhi University, earning a renowned

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page