top of page

The Price of a Vote: Decoding Freebie Culture in Indian Politics

Feb 5
5 min read

The Price of a Vote: Decoding Freebie Culture in Indian Elections:

In the vibrant, chaotic, and often unpredictable world of Indian democracy, a new term has taken centre stage in every news debate and "nukkad" discussion: Revari Culture or Freebie Culture. As an unaware student or voters, you might look at a manifesto promising free electricity, smartphones, or monthly cash transfers and think, "Hey, that’s great for the poor!" But if you scratch the surface, the reality is a complex web of economics, ethics, and desperate power moves.


The Rise of Freebie Culture in Indian Elections:

India isn't just the world’s largest democracy; it’s also one of the most competitive political markets. To win, parties need more than just a vision—they need a "hook." Historically, elections were fought on "Bijli, Sadak, Pani" (Electricity, Roads, Water). But today, that has evolved into "Free Bijli, Free Scooties, and Free Cash." The reason behind it is simple i.e., immediate gratification. For a family living below the poverty line, a promise of 2,000 rupees a month is more "real" than a promise of a 5-trillion-dollar economy that might happen in ten years. This shift started as a way to provide social security but has morphed into a full-blown bidding war. Whether it’s the North or the South, political parties are now trying to outdo each other in what they can give away for "free."

As Alexander Fraser Tytler says,

"A democracy cannot exist as a permanent form of government. It can only exist until the voters discover that they can vote themselves largesse from the public treasury." 


How Freebies Reaches the Masses:

The way these freebies are distributed is a masterclass in logistics and psychological marketing. It’s rarely just about handing over an item; it’s about branding.

Direct Benefit Transfers (DBT) is the modern way. Instead of giving a sack of grain that might get stolen by a middleman, the government pings money directly into a bank account. It’s clean, efficient, and makes the voter feel personally connected to the leader who "sent" the money. Another method is The Gender Focus because recently, there’s been a massive shift toward targeting women. Schemes providing free bus travel or monthly stipends specifically for women have shown that they can swing entire elections. Lastly We’ve seen everything from laptops and cycles to pressure cookers and colour TVs. However, the distribution isn't always fair. Often, these "gifts" reach those who are already vocal supporters, while the truly marginalized might still be left out due to a lack of paperwork or digital literacy.

The Vote Bank Impact that is turning Welfare into Loyalty:

This is where things get controversial. Does a freebie actually buy a vote? The short answer: Yes, but it’s complicated. In India, we have a "silent voter" phenomenon. A person might take a free sewing machine from Party A but still vote for Party B because they like their ideology. However, freebies create a "sense of obligation." When a party provides something that solves an immediate pain point like a gas cylinder it builds a massive amount of "Goodwill Capital."

The Impact on Policy: The problem is that when "freebies" become the only way to win, actual development takes a backseat. If a state spends 20% of its budget on free electricity, it has 20% less to spend on building new hospitals or improving the quality of colleges. It creates a Dependency Syndrome. Instead of asking for better jobs or better education so they can buy their own stuff, people start waiting for the next election cycle to see what they’ll get for free. This turns the citizen from a "stakeholder" into a "beneficiary."


Examples and Case Studies:

To understand this, look at the recent history of Indian states:

Punjab: Punjab is a stark reminder of a state that is trapped in a "debt trap" from a financial perspective. The state is offering free electricity up to 300 units every month to almost 90% of its households, besides offering free electricity to the agricultural sector. This commitment is estimated to result in a massive financial burden of 20,500 crore rupees for the state in 2025-26. As a result, Punjab's total debt is expected to touch 4.17 lakh crore rupees by the end of 2026. Punjab's debt level stands at 47%, which puts the state in a precarious situation where almost 23% of its total revenues are immediately spent on servicing the debt, leaving little room for innovation in industries and higher education infrastructure.


Tamil Nadu: As the trendsetter in the freebie economy, Tamil Nadu has been providing mixers, grinders, and laptops to influence the voting public. In the current budget for 2024-25, the government has allocated 13,720 crore rupees solely for the Magalir Urimai Thogai scheme (monthly cash allowance for women). Although such policies have contributed to social mobilization, the outstanding liabilities of the state have increased to over 7.5 lakh crore rupees. Although Tamil Nadu is a manufacturing centre, the worry is that the revenue deficit is being financed through borrowing. With more than 20% of the revenue spent on servicing debt and a massive amount spent on recurring subsidies, the state may be stagnating its capital expenditure.


Delhi: The Delhi model is unique because it operates in a high-revenue urban centre. The government offers 200 units of free power, 20,000 litres of free water, and unlimited free bus rides for women. A recent report from the Directorate of Economics and Statistics revealed that these subsidies, along with other transfers, now comprise nearly 35% of Delhi's total budgetary expenditure. For 2025-26, this subsidy bill is projected to jump to 34,520 crore rupees. While Delhi remains "revenue surplus" for now, the massive jump in projected spending—from 69,500 crore in 2024 to a steep 1 lakh crore in 2025—indicates a growing reliance on central loans and transfers to maintain this populist model.


The Economic Warning: The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) and the Supreme Court have both expressed concerns. If a state keeps giving things away for free without having the tax revenue to back it up, it’s headed for a crisis. It’s like using your credit card to buy gifts for your friends when you don’t even have a job, it feels good today, but the bank will come knocking tomorrow.


Analytical Comparison: State Spending on Freebies vs. Debt (2019 vs 2025-26)

State

Freebie Spending (2019-20)

Projected Freebie Cost (2025-26)

Total State Debt (Approx)

Revenue Spent on Debt/Interest


Punjab

₹9,500 Crore

₹20,500 Crore

₹4.17 Lakh Crore

23.50%


Tamil Nadu

₹6,200 Crore

₹13,720 Crore

₹7.50 Lakh Crore

21.00%


Delhi

₹3,200 Crore

₹34,520 Crore

₹38,000 Crore

8.50%


Rajasthan

₹5,500 Crore

₹12,000 Crore

₹5.40 Lakh Crore

18.00%








How to strike a balance?

So, is all "free stuff" bad? Not necessarily. There is a very thin line between "Merit Goods" and "Freebies." Giving free milk to malnourished children in schools (Mid-day meals) or providing free vaccinations is an investment in the country's future. That’s welfare. But giving away free gold coins or expensive electronics just days before an election, it is just bribe wrapped in a manifesto.

As students and the future electorate, we need to ask the right questions. Instead of asking "What will I get for free?", we should ask "How will this be paid for?" because, in reality, nothing is free. The money comes from the taxes paid on every biscuit packet or petrol litres your family buys as the saying goes:

"There is no such thing as a free lunch."

We need a shift from Distributive Politics to Developmental Politics. We need schools where we learn skills to earn, not just schemes that give us survival kits. The goal of a government should be to empower the citizen so much that they no longer need a freebie to survive.



Content by Sarthak Paliwal


Edited by Ashutosh Koul

Recent Posts

See All
THE BURDEN OF BEING SAFE

“Without community, there is no liberation, only the most vulnerable and temporary armistice between an individual and her oppression.” — Audre Lorde INTRODUCTION Don’t go out alone. Don’t go out afte

 
 
 
UNDER THE RUBBLE: THE SATYA NIKETAN TRAGEDY

Every year, the narrow lanes of Delhi swell with thousands of young students, carrying nothing but heavy luggage and even heavier dreams of securing a position at Delhi University, earning a renowned

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page